or
What Do You Care What People Think?
It was before nine in the morning and my father and I were on our way home from the grocery store. He was driving. It was a short trip, mostly to pick up some diapers for my 16-month-old before I headed off to a yoga class.
We were on vacation together – my parents, my mother-in-law, two of my sisters and their husbands and kids, my husband and kids – and with so many people around, I was virtually guaranteed a babysitter. The yoga class would be my second in two days – an anomaly in my current life – and I anticipated it being very challenging. My body was aching, but also awakened, already building upon the strength and energy of the day before.
We were quiet, riding along watching the tiny flowers pass at remarkable speed. They were moments of color in an outpouring of abundant, summer green.
"I bet I could go off all my medication if I went to yoga everyday," I said.
"Why don't you then?" my dad said. "You don't know the long term side-effects of the stuff you're taking now."
He's right, of course. I don't know the long-term side effects of my medication. No one does. The psychotropic drugs I take for depression and anxiety haven't been around much longer than twenty years. Doctors and research scientists think they're safe, and the FDA, by approving them, tells us their safe, but these bodies of knowledge have made mistakes, grave mistakes, before. I know this. But so far, given the known risks and the very real benefits, it's been a gamble I've been willing to take.
I thought about his question some more. Why don't I go to a vigorous yoga class seven days a week? One that challenges me physically, mentally and spiritually? One that leaves me high on endorphins and dopamine, one that leaves me strong and calm? I took a deep breath and fantasized about someone who looked like me, who was me, but who exuded a zen-like patience.
"I'm lazy," I answered. "Plus, getting to a yoga class, practicing for an hour and a half, and then getting home is a three hour commitment, which I can't really afford every day."
"Isn't there something in your neighborhood, something closer? Or can't you practice at home, to a video or something?"
I wasn't surprised by his questions. We had always had a close relationship and our discussions had always included my current mental state. Even from the beginning, long before I decided to take medication, when he knew almost nothing about depression or the newest drugs available to treat it, he was supportive, or tried his best to be. He read anything and everything he could on the topic, and passed along to me what he thought I might be interested in. And even though at first he was opposed to medication – even though he thought psychology and talk-therapy akin to astrology – he had, over the years, slowly come to regard mental illness and its treatment as the ever changing, complicated situation that it is.
"No, there's nothing close to my house and practicing at home isn't the same." I was already frustrated thinking about how little time I had for myself. This was, as always, followed by a fleeting sensation of guilt. How could I be so selfish when I had two beautiful, healthy children? When I had the luxury, the privilege even, to stay home with them? (Guilt – it's an emotion I feel guilty having and so quickly try to purge from my consciousness.)
Motherhood dawned on me five years ago with the birth of my daughter. At the time, I was mentally stable (on medication) and happily married. My husband and I were coming off the end of a very creative, productive, collaborative period. We were artistically prolific and had just moved to Brooklyn. We were both working and were ready to have kids. We were very excited when we found out I was pregnant.
Other than the first trimester’s completely debilitating nausea and a labor that lasted thirty-four hours, pregnancy and childbirth were easy. I was healthy, the baby was healthy, what more could I ask for? I had already quit taking most of my medication, something I had to do as soon as I became pregnant, and for a while I was riding high from the endorphins. It's the ultimate act of creation, creating a new life, and my life's work was set out before me.
My husband took a few days off from his job. My mother moved in temporarily. I had trouble breast-feeding. Nothing terribly unusual. My hormones raged, I resented my how my husband's life seemed practically unaltered compared to mine, I felt trapped inside my apartment. Nothing surprising. The baby wouldn't sleep, we disagreed about how to deal with it (and almost everything else, it sometimes seemed), and we kept on keeping on.
My father pulled the mini-van into a bank parking lot and I ran in to get some cash from the ATM. I considered what I’d said to him while the machine did its thing.
"Actually, that's really not true," I said when I got back to the car. "It's simple for me to say 'I'm lazy' or 'I don't have the time', but it's much more complicated than that. Even if everyone knew it was imperative for me to go to yoga, even if a doctor practically prescribed it, which would never happen, I would still be judged for it. I mean, a mother of two young children taking that much time for herself? And to do what, to exercise? Because really, that's what people think of yoga, you know."
"What do you care what people think?" my dad said. "If you could really get off all your medication, don't you think it would be worth it?"
Of course I did. Of course it would be worth it.
I remembered hearing the story of a Chinese woman who drastically lowered her blood pressure by playing ping-pong. I had passed along that tidbit of information to my mother, who had recently started taking blood-pressure medication while altering her super hectic, stressed out, go-go-go and do-everything-for-everyone-except-herself (yes, including me) life-style not at all. Needless to say, she didn't pick up ping-pong as a hobby.
"Yes," I told him, "but it's just not feasible. In fact, it's impossible. Imagine this scene: Both my kids are screaming or crying or both, the house is a disaster, it's dinnertime and there's nothing to cook, the dog needs to go out, my husband has tons and tons of work to get done (work he's getting paid to do), and I just wave bye-bye and walk out the door carrying my yoga mat."
I paused for effect. "Not gonna happen."
"As for caring about what other people think," I continued, really on a roll now, "it's not that simple. What 'people' think is really what our society values. It's what I've been taught to value since I was born. So it's not so much what 'people' think, it's what I think. Even though I might be able to rationally acknowledge that I need to go somewhere, every day, to calm my mind and stretch my body, irrationally I don't believe I'm worth it. It simply smacks of selfishness. And a big part of me believes that a selfish woman is not a good mother." I took a breath, a little proud of myself.
"But a happy mother is a better mother," my dad said. "And if you knew that what you were doing would make you a better mother . . . It's a bell-curve. At one end, there are the mothers who do nothing for themselves, for whom their children are their entire lives. At the other end, there are the mothers who do nothing for their children, women who don't make their children a priority at all. You just need to fall somewhere in between."
It was a good argument, at first. I imagined the bell curve charted out two-dimensionally, myself a little black spot somewhere between the apex and the selfless-mother end point. But then it hit me.
"Wait a minute, though. This is the entire problem," I said. "That once a woman has a child, once she becomes a mother, she is and will always be a point on this curve. She's always either a good mother or a bad mother or somewhere in between. So everything I do is a reflection of how good a mother I am. It's inescapable. I will always and forever be judged as a mother."
"Well," my dad said, "I don't know what to tell you. I don't know what you should do."
"I guess it's times like these that make people turn to God – make them look to the sky and plead, 'Just tell me what to do!'" I laughed.
"Well, don't do that," he said.
"Don't worry, I won't."
And I haven't – not yet, at least.