Friday, December 30, 2011

Motherhood

or
What Do You Care What People Think?


            It was before nine in the morning and my father and I were on our way home from the grocery store. He was driving. It was a short trip, mostly to pick up some diapers for my 16-month-old before I headed off to a yoga class.
            We were on vacation together – my parents, my mother-in-law, two of my sisters and their husbands and kids, my husband and kids – and with so many people around, I was virtually guaranteed a babysitter. The yoga class would be my second in two days – an anomaly in my current life – and I anticipated it being very challenging. My body was aching, but also awakened, already building upon the strength and energy of the day before.
            We were quiet, riding along watching the tiny flowers pass at remarkable speed. They were moments of color in an outpouring of abundant, summer green.
            "I bet I could go off all my medication if I went to yoga everyday," I said.
            "Why don't you then?" my dad said. "You don't know the long term side-effects of the stuff you're taking now."
            He's right, of course. I don't know the long-term side effects of my medication. No one does. The psychotropic drugs I take for depression and anxiety haven't been around much longer than twenty years. Doctors and research scientists think they're safe, and the FDA, by approving them, tells us their safe, but these bodies of knowledge have made mistakes, grave mistakes, before. I know this. But so far, given the known risks and the very real benefits, it's been a gamble I've been willing to take.
            I thought about his question some more. Why don't I go to a vigorous yoga class seven days a week? One that challenges me physically, mentally and spiritually? One that leaves me high on endorphins and dopamine, one that leaves me strong and calm? I took a deep breath and fantasized about someone who looked like me, who was me, but who exuded a zen-like patience.
            "I'm lazy," I answered. "Plus, getting to a yoga class, practicing for an hour and a half, and then getting home is a three hour commitment, which I can't really afford every day."
            "Isn't there something in your neighborhood, something closer? Or can't you practice at home, to a video or something?"
            I wasn't surprised by his questions. We had always had a close relationship and our discussions had always included my current mental state. Even from the beginning, long before I decided to take medication, when he knew almost nothing about depression or the newest drugs available to treat it, he was supportive, or tried his best to be. He read anything and everything he could on the topic, and passed along to me what he thought I might be interested in. And even though at first he was opposed to medication – even though he thought psychology and talk-therapy akin to astrology – he had, over the years, slowly come to regard mental illness and its treatment as the ever changing, complicated situation that it is.
            "No, there's nothing close to my house and practicing at home isn't the same." I was already frustrated thinking about how little time I had for myself. This was, as always, followed by a fleeting sensation of guilt. How could I be so selfish when I had two beautiful, healthy children? When I had the luxury, the privilege even, to stay home with them? (Guilt – it's an emotion I feel guilty having and so quickly try to purge from my consciousness.)

            Motherhood dawned on me five years ago with the birth of my daughter. At the time, I was mentally stable (on medication) and happily married. My husband and I were coming off the end of a very creative, productive, collaborative period. We were artistically prolific and had just moved to Brooklyn. We were both working and were ready to have kids. We were very excited when we found out I was pregnant.
            Other than the first trimester’s completely debilitating nausea and a labor that lasted thirty-four hours, pregnancy and childbirth were easy. I was healthy, the baby was healthy, what more could I ask for? I had already quit taking most of my medication, something I had to do as soon as I became pregnant, and for a while I was riding high from the endorphins. It's the ultimate act of creation, creating a new life, and my life's work was set out before me.
             My husband took a few days off from his job. My mother moved in temporarily. I had trouble breast-feeding. Nothing terribly unusual. My hormones raged, I resented my how my husband's life seemed practically unaltered compared to mine, I felt trapped inside my apartment. Nothing surprising. The baby wouldn't sleep, we disagreed about how to deal with it (and almost everything else, it sometimes seemed), and we kept on keeping on.
            My father pulled the mini-van into a bank parking lot and I ran in to get some cash from the ATM. I considered what I’d said to him while the machine did its thing.

            "Actually, that's really not true," I said when I got back to the car. "It's simple for me to say 'I'm lazy' or 'I don't have the time', but it's much more complicated than that. Even if everyone knew it was imperative for me to go to yoga, even if a doctor practically prescribed it, which would never happen, I would still be judged for it. I mean, a mother of two young children taking that much time for herself? And to do what, to exercise? Because really, that's what people think of yoga, you know."
            "What do you care what people think?" my dad said. "If you could really get off all your medication, don't you think it would be worth it?"
            Of course I did. Of course it would be worth it.
            I remembered hearing the story of a Chinese woman who drastically lowered her blood pressure by playing ping-pong. I had passed along that tidbit of information to my mother, who had recently started taking blood-pressure medication while altering her super hectic, stressed out, go-go-go and do-everything-for-everyone-except-herself (yes, including me) life-style not at all. Needless to say, she didn't pick up ping-pong as a hobby.
            "Yes," I told him, "but it's just not feasible. In fact, it's impossible. Imagine this scene: Both my kids are screaming or crying or both, the house is a disaster, it's dinnertime and there's nothing to cook, the dog needs to go out, my husband has tons and tons of work to get done (work he's getting paid to do), and I just wave bye-bye and walk out the door carrying my yoga mat."
            I paused for effect. "Not gonna happen."
            "As for caring about what other people think," I continued, really on a roll now, "it's not that simple. What 'people' think is really what our society values. It's what I've been taught to value since I was born. So it's not so much what 'people' think, it's what I think. Even though I might be able to rationally acknowledge that I need to go somewhere, every day, to calm my mind and stretch my body, irrationally I don't believe I'm worth it. It simply smacks of selfishness. And a big part of me believes that a selfish woman is not a good mother." I took a breath, a little proud of myself.
            "But a happy mother is a better mother," my dad said. "And if you knew that what you were doing would make you a better mother . . . It's a bell-curve. At one end, there are the mothers who do nothing for themselves, for whom their children are their entire lives. At the other end, there are the mothers who do nothing for their children, women who don't make their children a priority at all. You just need to fall somewhere in between."
            It was a good argument, at first. I imagined the bell curve charted out two-dimensionally, myself a little black spot somewhere between the apex and the selfless-mother end point. But then it hit me.
            "Wait a minute, though. This is the entire problem," I said. "That once a woman has a child, once she becomes a mother, she is and will always be a point on this curve. She's always either a good mother or a bad mother or somewhere in between. So everything I do is a reflection of how good a mother I am. It's inescapable. I will always and forever be judged as a mother."
            "Well," my dad said, "I don't know what to tell you. I don't know what you should do."
            "I guess it's times like these that make people turn to God – make them look to the sky and plead, 'Just tell me what to do!'" I laughed.
            "Well, don't do that," he said.
            "Don't worry, I won't."
            And I haven't – not yet, at least.

Friday, September 23, 2011

Point of View, by Shel Silverstein

Thanksgiving dinner's sad and thankless 
Christmas dinner's dark and blue 
When you stop and try to see it 
From the turkey's point of view. 

Sunday dinner isn't sunny 
Easter feasts are just bad luck 
When you see it from the viewpoint 
Of a chicken or a duck. 

Oh how I once loved tuna salad 
Pork and lobsters, lamb chops too 
'Til I stopped and looked at dinner 
From the dinner's point of view. 

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

Regarding the Death Penalty


John Malkovich says, regarding the death penalty:

“Without a death penalty, whether it’s ever applied or not, murderers are the final arbiters of life and death. Not the society, not the juries or judges – but only a murderer can decide who merits living and who merits dying. That strikes me as not an ideal societal statement.”

Actually, this strikes me as the ideal societal statement.

For if a murderer is someone who “decides who merits living and who merits dying”, then those who make this decision – i.e., the state of Georgia, the state of Texas, the Supreme Court, we the people – are murderers. 

Sunday, September 18, 2011

Drift


When I look down at a platter of raw steaks, waiting to go on the grill:

I don’t see the poor bovines 
– standing in their own shit – 
suffering before slaughter.
I don’t see the overfed Americans 
– clothes too tight – 
suffering from cancer and heart disease.

I see the glaring gap between these two.
I see the disconnect, the lack, the loss.
I see a slow and savage drift, movement
separating us from the knowledge of our forbearers:
knowledge of, an understanding of, the cycle of life and death.

Friday, September 16, 2011

Scratch-off Prize



This is a photograph of a poster I took on a Metro North train. It’s an advertisement for the New York State Lottery. The tag line at bottom reads: Good things happen in an instant.

Hmmm . . . let’s see, if I’m reading this correctly, and I think I am, one example of a good thing is . . . woman-as-scratch-off-prize. 

Wow. 

(I don't think I need to say anything else.)

Monday, June 6, 2011

Open Letter to The Parents of Junior Kumon Students

Open Letter to The Parents of Junior Kumon Students, with a implicit nod to Ms. Goldman, mother of Huxton and Eze, two of the children discussed in the recent New York Times article regarding the recent proliferation of “Learning Centers” like Kumon and Sylvan.


6 June 2011

Dear Parents of Junior Kumon students,                                                                         


            The picture of Eze that accompanies the article says it all: her barely-three-year-old hand and chubby fingers pressed into her head, her elbow resting on the table as she searches the page in front of her for the number that matches the number on the little plastic disc she’s holding; the very un-joyful look on her face – whether it be concentration or boredom or worry that borders on burgeoning anxiety.
            Or is it the words of the little girl’s instructor? “Is that how we write a 12? Erase it.” Then:
“This is a sloppy 12, Eze. Go ahead, a one and a two. Smaller. Much better.” Then: “Neater. Come on, you can do it.”
            Or maybe, ultimately, the grotesqueness of the situation is best represented by what the instructor says next: “You’ll get an extra sticker if you do a perfect thirteen.” It’s a simple bribe, an “if, then” statement as in “if you eat two more bites of salmon, then you can have dessert” or “if you don’t stop acting like a turd, then you won’t get to play any more video games.”
            I use the noun form of the familiar adjective ‘grotesque’ to describe this scene for many reasons, not the least of which is because the adult seems to have resorted to bribery, her saving this method for last implying knowledge of the method’s inherent evil.
            You’re probably thinking, Evil? What is the harm in this kind of behavior modification?[1] Why shouldn’t children have their treats taken away if they don’t act a certain way? That’s the way the world works; that’s life, right?[2] So instead of waiting for you to actually ask, I’ll just tell you.
            There are two main problems with bribery, the first being the most obvious – the result. Your children will learn that this is the way the world works and before long they’ll turn it back on you. I’ll go to bed if I can watch one more episode of Diego. This is tolerable, maybe. As an adult, you can laugh this off and end any further negotiations. You can put your foot down, so to speak, and force your child to go to bed. Maybe. But one day soon you’ll hear your child say to another child, “If you don’t _______ (fill in the blank), I won’t be your friend,” and this will be a sad day. I know what you’re thinking: Every child says something like this at some time in his or her life. I know that, of course, I’m not an idiot. Kids learn from other kids and they try it out for themselves. The difference being that your child is the one the other children are learning from. The other kids will try out this new-fangled idea and when it gets no traction at home, they’ll probably drop it. With your child, however, this is the way his or her world functions.
            The second problem with bribery is the displacement of pleasure. Since bribery depends on the creation of a goal outside the activity at hand, what is communicated is that whatever your child is being asked to do is not valuable enough to warrant doing it without some other motivating factor. Take learning to read for example. What you are telling your child is that reading is not enough, that we must have a reason, other than reading itself, to read.
            This reminds me of one of Bill Hicks’ skits. He was talking about touring the United States, about being on the road and eating at a Waffle House, and he tells the story of being asked by a waffle house waitress, “What you reading for?” Hicks’ pauses, and then he says – in case a few people didn’t catch it ­– “She didn’t ask me, ‘What you reading?’ but ‘What you reading for?’” He goes on to re-enact the following moments, to wonder aloud at the novelty of such a question. “No one had ever asked me that before, not ‘What are you reading?’ but ‘What are you reading for?’”[3]
            I find myself forced to ask you the same question, parents: What are you reading for? Apparently, simply reading is not enough for you, because if it were, if you recognized reading and writing, indeed all intellectual curiosity, for what it is – not only pleasurable but the very essence of being alive – then you wouldn’t be sending your toddlers to a tutoring center. You wouldn’t be sending them because you’d understand that kids naturally gravitate to what is fun; that all you really need to do is get out of their fucking way.

            Perhaps I’ve erred in sending this letter to you, parents. Perhaps this letter should be addressed to the Kumon academy itself. I could begin by admonishing them for cashing in on our culture of fear, like this:

Dear Kumon,
            People send their toddlers to be tutored for the same reason the Patriot Act passed congress – fear. Kumon, and similar quote-unquote learning centers, make money because parents fear their children won’t measure up to other children. It’s simple. You know this, I know this, and often, if not mostly, the parents know this. The reason why you, Kumon and other quote-unquote learning centers, continue to succeed, then, is not in spite of their being aware that their parenting decisions are based on fear, but rather because of it. We live in a culture of fear, etc., etc.

            But, no, I won’t write this letter. I won’t because however wrong it may be to take advantage of, to exploit, a population’s collective conscious or unconscious fear, however repulsive I find it, I respect (in a sense) them for doing all they can to make money. Kumon is a business, after all, and it’s Kumon’s job to make money, so long as the services they offer are legal.
            And what is your job, parents? Your job is to protect your children. Your job is to protect them from the vultures that come dressed as Junior Kumon instructors.





[1]  Because that’s what it is. Trying to get a child to behave a certain way is just behavior modification.
[2] This kind of reasoning, the ‘that’s life, you better get used to it’ reasoning is easily dismissed. Life is also murder, rape, war, cancer, orphans, and genocide, but we don’t expose our children to these realities, do we?
[3] His punch line is quick and sharp, not really true, but very funny: “Hmmm,” he says, rubbing his chin, “I guess it’s so I won’t end up being a Waffle House waitress like you.”

Sunday, June 5, 2011

If You're Lucky



            There's a moment that comes – maybe, if you're lucky – when you're faced with the future, and you attempt to come to terms with it. There's a moment that comes – maybe, if you're lucky – when you question whether or not every day will be as bad as the current one.
            This is an unanswerable question, of course. Or rather, this question can be answered but never definitely, never 100%. Because there will always be questions, we can never know the shape of things to come. Or rather, we can never know the shape of things to come because there will always be questions.
            In any case, when this moment comes, we can guess, and with the help of experts, our guesses can be pretty accurate. Not 100%. I’m not saying that. But 99% or 99.9% even, and this is close enough for some decisions – decisions like suicide, for example.
            Let’s take emphysema. When every day is more painful than the one before, why suffer? There has to be a reason to live other than living itself, other than basic respiration, circulation. Maybe it is your children, or your grandchildren. Maybe it is your partner/spouse. Maybe it is your dog or cat, and the pleasure they bring trumps the pain of existence. Or maybe not. For there is no equality, except in our imagination. One side is always bigger, stronger, faster, more painful, more pleasurable, whatever – one side is always more of it than the other side.
            So what I’m saying is, I don’t blame David Foster Wallace for hanging himself. As sick as it is, I don’t blame him for duct taping his wrists together just to prevent him from changing his mind.[1]
            I’m listening to Bon Iver’s first album[2], and I hear this line: Some day my pain will rock you. Harness your blame and walk through. This is what depression is – pain and blame, and being rocked by it – and I think of DFW. I think of myself, too; I think of depression, of everyone depressed. These thoughts are further depressing, but at the same time, DFW was proactive. He did exactly this – he harnessed his blame and walked through – as corny as it sounds. To wish for an alternate reality, to wish for his not duct taping his hands together, to wish for his escaping – these wishes are selfish.

            Just last week, I found a clue to DFW’s suicide.[3] On page 29 of ASFTINDA[4], in discussing TV critics and their dullness, he writes, “These scholars are like people who despise – I mean big-time, long-term despise – their spouses or jobs but won’t split up or quit.” DFW didn’t want to be one of these people, and he despised – I mean big-time, long-term despised – himself.



[1] I don’t blame him, but when I read a sentence like this one, which comes as the end of his essay “Ticket to the Fair”: I myself am constructing a mental list of the violations I would undergo before I’d let anyone haul me ass-first to a great height and swing me like high-altitude beef, my body aches. It’s physical, I mean, this longing, and I didn’t even know him.
[2] “For Emma, Forever Ago”
[3] By using the word ‘clue’ I am not implying that his suicide is a mystery in need of being solved. From what I’ve read, his choice to commit suicide is/was understandable. However, as a great writer and thinker, he is a public figure, and therefore exists in at least two spheres: the public and private. I am someone who did not know him personally; I knew him/only know him through his writing. His suicide, then, as most of his life, is and will forever remain a mystery to me.
[4] A Supposedly Fun Thing I’ll Never Do Again

What happens to your Facebook account when you die?

            My mom sent my husband a text tonight telling us my cousin Dana died yesterday.[1] She was a fifty-year-old ex-methamphetamine addict and lived alone in a duplex on the outskirts of Wake Village, itself a suburb of Texarkana, Texas.
            Meals-on-Wheels found her body earlier today. She was sitting on the edge of her bed, her oxygen tank pulled up next to her, the tank’s clear plastic tubing lying on the carpeted floor. My cousin had pulmonary hypertension, meaning the blood vessels in her lungs were constricted, meaning blood had a hard time circulating through her lungs, meaning her body was always in want of more oxygen. Hence, the oxygen tank that sat by the side of her bed.
            It is not known exactly what happened. My aunt – my mother’s older sister – doesn’t want an autopsy done, and who can blame her? What does it matter whether my cousin suffocated trying to get to the oxygen tank or had a heart attack from the stress of it all?[2] What matters is she died alone, struggling to breathe.

            Dana sent me a friend request on Facebook over a year ago, but I never responded.
            “What could it hurt?” one of my older sisters asked me. We were discussing how handle such a thoroughly modern problem, one of the problems that social networks such as Facebook have given rise to. Before Facebook allowed us to stay connected, we were allowed to stay disconnected. If you didn’t want daily or weekly contact with extended family members, you simply moved away. Most of my extended family lives in Texas. I live in Brooklyn.
            “Agreeing to be her ‘friend’ just gives her access to your pictures, right?" my sister continued. "And you can always choose to block any of her comments.” True, I admitted, but still. Still, what? My sister glared at me.
            I didn’t have an answer for her. Perhaps, even, I didn’t have an answer for myself. That I had simply chosen not to think about it was, I now see, a cruel act on my part. When she was alive, she was annoying – her desperation embarrassing, it revealing too much. When she was alive, she was an ex-meth addict, sometimes heavy drinker without a job who depended on my mother for day-to-day survival. Now that she was dead, she was a sad, lonely, sick woman living by herself in a duplex my mother bought for her; she was an older cousin who’d once been a big part of my life but was no more.




[1] May 17, 2011. I am sure my mother would have sent me a text message on my phone, but I had left my phone somewhere (I wouldn’t say ‘lost’ – I almost always find everything I misplace) and was depending on my husband and his phone for communication with the outside world.
[2] She also had heart problems, not necessarily a result of her history of using speed, but not helped by it, either.

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Two Soldiers

April 4, 2011

The two soldiers stood one behind the other on the slow incline of the long ramp in Grand Central. They were dressed in desert fatigues – boots, hats, belts, guns, everything. I approached them from behind, walking down to the dining concourse. I could see both of their heads bent forward. Their arms were raised to hold whatever they were holding – that I couldn’t tell. As I got closer, though, I saw. Each held an iphone and stared into its small screen. Both men were absolutely still, the only movement from their fingers, from their eyelids blinking. They were sending text messages.

Everywhere I Look I See the Hunted

Sunday May 1, 2011

Standing in Central Park not fifty yards the south entrance to the zoo, I see a big white bird in the trees. It has small brown spots, almost like freckles, and I think it’s a falcon. For a reason I cannot quite determine, I want to say it’s a peregrine falcon. Maybe I’ve seen a picture of one in one of my children’s books. Maybe it’s the only kind of falcon I know. Maybe there’s no such thing as a peregrine falcon, but it sounds good.

I turn to a couple of older women standing behind me and I see a small crowd has grown. Everyone with her head tilted upward, eyes following the big bird as it hops every few minutes to another spot.

“Is that a peregrine falcon?” I ask one of the women.

“I don’t know.”

I look back to the bird but my ears linger behind. She turns to her friend and says. She asked if it were a peregrine falcon. I like the way I sound in another’s voice.

There is a blue jay darting around the falcon. It’s making loud noises as it flies closer and closer, finally striking the white bird’s back. It keeps doing this and I realize it must be trying to scare the falcon away. I’ve always thought of a blue jay as a large and aggressive bird, but in this case – its size diminished by the enormity of the falcon – I see it as helpless. There is no way a blue jay can prevent a falcon from . . .. Its desperation is painful to watch.

The big bird doesn’t even flinch when it’s hit. Its feathers aren’t even ruffled. Yet the jay keeps trying – squawking and dive-bombing the falcon until the falcon makes its final hop.

The jay has quit squawking now, and I realize I’m holding my breath. Maybe the jay is too. It stays perched on a small branch ten feet from its nest when the falcon lands. The raptor’s large talons rummage through the delicate nest. A small egg falls to the ground. Someone behind me says, There one goes.

Wide white wings open, and with one downward motion, the bird rises. In its talons, the entire nest. Two more, now three, four flaps of its awesome wings, and the falcon is gone.

Thursday, April 28, 2011

Shoah, Night & Fog, Zeitoun

The horror! The horror!

Whatever Conrad meant by it – I don't care. However it functioned in Heart of Darkness – I don't remember, at least not exactly. To me, now, the power of the repetition of this simple phrase lies in its ability to suggest both the enormity of evil and the failure of language to represent it.

That both of these things can be taken together, that both can be – and in fact, are – simultaneously extracted from the same phrase: it is walking through the only door available and having your knowledge of the entire world evaporate.

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Playing the Piano

Dixon Place 25th Anniversary Party

April 7, 2011

Listening to him (anyone, almost) play the piano and sing a pop song (a Ryan Adams cover), I think of one of my favorite sentiments, something Holden Caulfield said. It was right after he got to the city. He was sitting in a bar listening to somebody play the piano, and he said, “If I played the piano, I’d play it in the god-damned closet.” That pretty much sums it up for me.

But if you need more, there’s this, which applies to everything, almost: Do you really need that many notes? Really? Because my idea of perfection is a Fugazi guitar solo.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Some Numbers from the Abstract Expressionist Show at MoMA, Feb 2011


from Day At The Museum*

Appendix I

Number of times, previous to this show, that a full floor in the new Museum has been devoted to a single theme: 0

Total number of female artists represented in exhibit[1]: 10

Chance that one of their husbands also has work in show: 1 in 2

Total number of male artists represented in exhibit[2]: 50

Number of non-textual pieces by Elaine de Kooning[3]: 0

Number of pieces by Lee Krasner: 3

Number of pieces by Willem de Kooning: 7

Percent of exhibit Jackson Pollock’s work constitutes: 7

Percent of exhibit women’s work constitutes: 14

Chance that a security guard working on any floor of the exhibit was both African-American and female: 1 in 13

Chance that a security guard working on any floor of the exhibit was both African-American or Latino and male: 11 in 13

Ratio of African-Americans or Latinos viewing exhibit to those guarding it: 1/12

Age Hedda Sterne turned this past August: 100

Total number of works of art on display in this exhibit: 334

Percent of these works owned by the Museum: 100

*Figures from the exhibit Abstract Expressionist New York on the 4th, 3rd, and 2nd floors of the Museum of Modern Art in New York City on Thursday, February 3, 2011, from 11 a.m. until 3 p.m.



[1] Louise Bourgeois, Dorothy Dehner, Elaine de Kooning, Helen Frankenthauler, Grace Hartigan, Lee Krasner, Joan Mitchell, Louise Nevelson, Jeanne Reynal, Hedda Sterne

[2] Baziotes, Blaine, Brooks, Cage, Callahan, Caponigro, Chappell, DeCarava, de Kooning, Feldman, Ferber, Francis, Frank, Fuller, Gottlieb, Gorky, Graves, Guston, Hare, Harrison, Haytner, Hoffman, Kanemitsu, Kiesler, Kline, Lewiton, Lippold, Lipton, Lye, Lyons, Motherwell, Newman, Niemeyer, Noguchi, Okada, Pollock, Pousette-Dart, Rauschenberg, Reinhardt, Rivers, Rothko, Siskind, Smith, Sommer, Stamos, Still, Tobey, Tomlin, Tworkov, White

[3] Only Elaine de Kooning included in show: page of text in journal/magazine as part of table display in section entitled “The Image in Poetry and Painting” – itself part of “Ideas Not Theories” on 3rd floor.